Maybe your mom berated you in front of your friends or your dad didn’t show up for.....anything. Maybe your sister teased you about the “potholes” on your face or your brother beat you up.....again. Maybe you told your best friend an intimate secret and found that secret “all over school.” Or worse, maybe your uncle touched you in a wrong place and somehow you couldn’t or wouldn’t tell someone.
Possibly you can’t remember the circumstances but can remember the sense of pain, violation, and surprise often associated. This was true of me--I just remember I was around 6, it had to do with my mother and a reprimand, and I somehow felt betrayed by the person I had worshipped up to that point. How could she?
These experiences are devastating because trust is so important. Webster’s dictionary defines trust as a “basis for reliance, faith, or hope,” and we are born needing and wanting to trust we will taken care of and loved. Trust is also the essence of the spiritual life, where we have the vulnerability to “let go and let God” because we trust He will be there for us.
No wonder we’re left reeling when this trust gets ruptured. And when it does we’re left with a question: what happens next? For some, the experience is hurtful but leaves a small scar, becoming an isolated experience outweighed by mostly positives with their family and friends. But for others the rupture evolves into a breach, as betrayal after betrayal wears down the hopeful heart and distrust becomes the norm.
Breaches lead to self-protection which can lead to a vow: “I’m going to shut down and not let anyone hurt me again.” There is power in such a vow, a way to take control in an uncontrollable environment. Children aren’t equipped to sort out painful experiences and closing the floodgates may be the best decision at the time.
But as our life moves on the cure becomes the disease when battening down the emotional hatches becomes the default setting. We are programmed to pull away and protect ourselves in our relationships and have trouble getting close. True intimacy is then replaced by coping mechanisms and role adaptations as the substitutes for trust replace trust itself.
When we’re born to trust and hardwired to mistrust, when we want to let go but need to hold on, we are in conflict. And with a bit of courage we look for a solution: Therapy? God? Both? Involving God is usually a good starting point but many harbor grudges, wondering where He was when their spirit was being broken.
This is where faith comes in, both in God and in the possibility of trusting again. For some it may feel like a leap: I have no reason to trust but I sense the need so I’ll try. Others have had glimpses of either God’s provision or of life before their trust went south and decide to take a risk. For most the gravitation to faith involves the acknowledgement of the Roman soldier: “I believe--help me with my unbelief.”
This is certainly the paradox I’ve experienced as I’ve spent a lifetime sorting through the breach I felt and the vow I took. For years I had anger at the protective side of me that seemed to set up roadblocks every time I wanted closeness. But more recently I’ve replaced the anger with a conversation, thanking this protector for wanting to shield me but seeing if we can focus on a new set of priorities.
Over the years I’ve also gained perspective on how to turn my weaknesses with trust into a strength. Sometimes those with an abundance of trust can become complacent in seeking God; my fears and pain in this area have possibly made me more hungry, not to mention more empathetic to those who struggle like myself.
And the Hound of Heaven has done His work, helping me with perspective and slowly but surely helping me grieve and move on. He indeed was there when my spirit was broken, and has been there throughout the healing process. Mistrust to trust is an arduous journey, but with faith in God and the possibility of change, we can move past painful memories and open our hearts anew.